The Tom Storey ShowDecember 31, 2023

Speculators’ Exit SHOCKS 2024 Canadian Housing with Nolan Matthias

About this episode Mortgage broker and YouTuber Nolan Matthias closes out 2023 with Tom Storey and Steve Kish by working through five big questions for Canadian real estate in 2024: whether prices have bottomed, whether rates have peaked, whether to lock in, whether investors will return and whether affordability will improve. His core advice is to base mortgage decisions on fundamentals, not forecasts. Hosts: Tom Storey (Toronto) and Steve Karrasch...

About this episode

Mortgage broker and YouTuber Nolan Matthias closes out 2023 with Tom Storey and Steve Kish by working through five big questions for Canadian real estate in 2024: whether prices have bottomed, whether rates have peaked, whether to lock in, whether investors will return and whether affordability will improve. His core advice is to base mortgage decisions on fundamentals, not forecasts.

Hosts: Tom Storey (Toronto) and Steve Karrasch (Greater Vancouver)
Guest: Nolan Matthias, Mortgage broker and YouTube creator
Episode: December 31, 2023, about 73 minutes
Watch this episode on YouTube or listen above.

Key takeaways

  • Nolan calls volatility the theme of 2023 and warns against making large decisions based on forecasts, which he says were widely wrong that year.
  • He flags shipping disruptions through the Red Sea and Suez Canal as an inflation risk that could quickly change the outlook for rates.
  • Nolan expected Bank of Canada cuts of about 0.5 to 1 percentage point in 2024 but called it close to a coin flip. Steve guessed holds until a first cut on June 5, then July, then one more in the fall.
  • With the five year bond yield near 3.08%, five year insured fixed rates were about 5.19% to 5.29%. The last time the yield was that level, in May 2023, fixed rates were near 4.59%, so Nolan expected fixed rates to fall in early 2024.
  • His rule is to take the lowest rate available when you get the mortgage. In late 2023 that meant fixed rather than variable.
  • He advises against a big bank five year fixed if rates may fall, because penalties can be three to five times higher than at lenders like MCAP, First National or CMLS.
  • Nolan distinguishes investors from speculators: speculators who bet on quick gains have left, while professional investors are moving into CMHC financed purpose built rentals after the GST was removed on new rental construction.
  • In the Fraser Valley, Steve says a buyer needed around 40% down to break even on a rental, and one client found all 19 of their saved $500,000 one bedroom listings had sold before they could book showings.

Have prices bottomed?

Nolan says inflation adjusted Canadian home prices fell about 20% from the peak by 2023, and he did not expect a deeper drop in 2024, though the exact bottom may only be clear years later. Steve says his market bottomed around the end of 2022 and was picking up again over the holidays as inventory fell below about 4,000 listings.

Population growth and affordability

The hosts discuss Statistics Canada figures showing population growth of about 430,000 in the third quarter of 2023, with the population passing 40.5 million. Nolan says affordability always rebalances eventually, through higher incomes, lower prices or lower borrowing costs, but expects that to take years in the largest markets.

Other perspectives

Nolan and Steve are critical of the federal government’s Canadian Mortgage Charter, which Nolan sees as restating practices lenders already followed. Supporters of the charter argue that putting those expectations in writing gives struggling borrowers clearer protections, such as temporary amortization extensions and fee relief. Many economists also point out that immigration supports labour force and economic growth, while agreeing that housing supply has not kept pace.

Update since this episode

Steve’s guess on timing was close. The Bank of Canada made its first cut on June 5, 2024 and followed with cuts in July, September, October and December, lowering its policy rate from 5% to 3.25% by the end of 2024, more than either guest forecast.

Views are those of the hosts and guest, not financial, legal or tax advice.

Questions answered in this episode

Should I choose a fixed or variable mortgage?

Nolan Matthias’s rule is to take the lowest rate available when you get the mortgage rather than betting on forecasts. In late 2023 five year fixed rates were well below variable rates, so he favoured fixed.

Why avoid a big bank five year fixed mortgage when rates may fall?

Nolan says big bank prepayment penalties can be three to five times higher than at monoline lenders such as MCAP, First National or CMLS. If rates drop and you want to switch, a high penalty can wipe out the savings.

How are fixed mortgage rates set in Canada?

Five year fixed rates are priced mainly off the five year Government of Canada bond yield plus the lender’s spread. In late 2023 that spread was unusually wide, which is why Nolan expected fixed rates to come down in early 2024.

What is the difference between a real estate investor and a speculator?

Nolan describes speculators as people betting on quick price gains, often late in life and with high leverage. Investors buy for fundamentals such as cash flow or adding value, and in 2023 many were shifting to purpose built rentals financed through CMHC programs.

Did the Bank of Canada cut rates in 2024?

Yes. It began cutting on June 5, 2024 and cut five times that year, bringing its policy rate from 5% to 3.25% by December 2024.

Related: The Tom Storey Show episode guide · Next episode: Canadians Are Worried About Paying Their Mortgages in 2024 with Alex McFadyen

Show notes

***Start Your Realty Ninja Real Estate Website***

Free Trial and 20% Off your first year: 

https://www.realtyninja.com/tom

– – – 

Happy New Year!

You might be happy to know that it appears that you wont have to compete with many speculators in the 2024 Canadian housing market as they have all but dried up!

On This week’s episode of The Tom Storey Show, Steve Karrasch and Tom Storey catch up with the show’s most frequent guest, Nolan Matthias of Mortgage 360 and Canadian Real Estate YouTuber fame, to discuss investing, speculation, mortgages and a whole lot more. 

Connect with Nolan: 

Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@NolanMatthias

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@REALESTATE100SHOW

– – – 

*** Need Home or Property Insurance? *** 

Use SQUARE ONE: Tenants, Landlords and Home Owners Save $20 with Square One Insurance using this link:  https://www.squareone.ca/thetomstoreyshow?offer_code=TTSS

🎥  Learn how to improve your message with the #1 Real Estate Video Course or my YouTube Course for Real Estate *** https://videocourselogin.com/ ***

💵  DISCOUNT CODE: TomShow  💵

AUDIO PODCAST LINKS:

Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/7wEEPUUhaC8g2CsIwJetbd

Apple Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/…/the-tom…/id1627632474

Amazon: https://music.amazon.ca/…/the-tom-storey-show-with…?

TOM STOREY

Book a call with Tom: https://calendly.com/TomStorey

Tom's YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/TomStorey/videos

The Storey Team, Royal LePage Signature: https://storeyteam.ca/

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thestoreyteam/

FaceBook: https://www.facebook.com/thestoreyteam

STEVE KARRASCH

Book a call with Steve: https://calendly.com/stevekarrasch

Steve's YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/KarraschRealProperties/videos

Karrasch Real Properties, Macdonald Realty: https://www.krproperties.ca/

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/karrasch_real_properties/

FaceBook: https://www.facebook.com/KarraschRealProperties/

Need VIDEO GEAR? Shop Steve's Amazon Store: https://amzn.to/45cIBbU

The opinions expressed herein are solely that of Steve Karrasch PREC and Tom Storey, not Macdonald Realty, Royal LePage Signature, TREB or the FVREB and should not be misconstrued as advice or the basis of an agency relationship whatsoever. Nor should any of this content be considered or used as financial advice.  Please consult your professional advisor prior to taking action on any decisions relating to the matters discussed in these videos. This communication is not intended to cause or induce breach of an existing agency agreement.

Read More

It’s Your Storey & It All Begins Right Here.
It’s Your Storey & It All Begins Right Here.It’s Your Storey & It All Begins Right Here.