About this episode Mortgage broker Alex McFadyen of Flow Mortgage Co., known online as the Mortgage Pug, joins Tom Storey and Steve Kish to start 2024. He explains what homeowners can do when a renewal jumps from a 2.5% rate to around 6%, why the bank’s renewal letter is rarely the best offer, how alternative lenders compare, and the mortgage rule changes the three of them would like to see....
About this episode
Mortgage broker Alex McFadyen of Flow Mortgage Co., known online as the Mortgage Pug, joins Tom Storey and Steve Kish to start 2024. He explains what homeowners can do when a renewal jumps from a 2.5% rate to around 6%, why the bank’s renewal letter is rarely the best offer, how alternative lenders compare, and the mortgage rule changes the three of them would like to see.
Hosts: Tom Storey (Toronto) and Steve Karrasch (Greater Vancouver)
Guest: Alex McFadyen, Mortgage broker
Episode: January 7, 2024, about 78 minutes
Watch this episode on YouTube or listen above.
Key takeaways
- Alex says some clients facing renewal are close to tears when a payment jumps from about $2,100 to $3,000 a month, but so far he has not met anyone with no options.
- He says a bank’s renewal letter is often 0.5% to 1% above what the market offers, so homeowners should compare rates before signing.
- Options at renewal include shopping lenders through a broker, re-amortizing back to 25 or 30 years, and consolidating credit cards, lines of credit and car loans that strain monthly cash flow.
- Insured mortgages could switch lenders at renewal without a new stress test, but most uninsured borrowers had to re-qualify at a much higher rate.
- At the late 2023 peak, with three year fixed rates near 6.93%, some borrowers had to qualify near 9% and moved to alternative lenders whose rates were only about 0.25% to 0.5% higher, plus a fee of about 1% to 2%.
- In one example, a bank offered a renewing client 6.94% while Alex’s team secured 5.41% and set up a HELOC for a future purchase.
- Steve would cap mortgage penalties at three months’ interest and require lenders to show the current penalty in online banking, while Tom wants larger prepayment privileges.
- Alex wanted 30 year amortizations restored for insured first time buyers and a lighter stress test for uninsured renewals and switches.
Alternative lenders are not what they used to be
Alex says the old A, B and C lender labels are now more like a sliding scale. Many alternative or B lenders are well capitalized, and in late 2023 some offered rates close to or even below the big banks for certain terms. He expects more borrowers, especially the self employed and those with side income, to use them in the years ahead.
Bank changes and competition
Alex notes RBC’s purchase of HSBC Canada could reduce rate competition, since HSBC was known for low advertised rates through brokers. He says Scotiabank stepped back from new mortgage business in early 2023 and later tied its best rates to customers taking other products, and that bank mortgage specialists sell under the bank’s licence rather than holding their own mortgage licence.
Money mindset
Alex encourages people to ask why they make the money decisions they do, learn how appreciation and compound interest work, and value their time. Steve argues many people spend too much on short term experiences instead of building for the future, while Alex places more weight on growing income and enjoying experiences along the way.
Update since this episode
Several ideas from this episode later became policy. From November 21, 2024, OSFI no longer required uninsured borrowers who switch lenders at renewal to pass the stress test. In December 2024 the federal government expanded 30 year amortizations to all first time buyers and buyers of new builds and raised the insured mortgage price cap to $1.5 million. The Bank of Canada began cutting its policy rate on June 5, 2024, and RBC completed its purchase of HSBC Canada in March 2024.
Views are those of the hosts and guest, not financial, legal or tax advice.
Questions answered in this episode
What should I do if my mortgage renewal payment is going up a lot?
Alex McFadyen suggests comparing offers rather than signing the bank’s renewal letter, looking at re-amortizing to a longer period, and reviewing consumer debt such as credit cards and car loans that may be squeezing your monthly cash flow.
Is my bank’s renewal offer a good rate?
Often not. Alex says renewal letters are commonly 0.5% to 1% above what is available in the market. In one case a bank offered 6.94% and his team found 5.41%.
Do I need to pass the stress test to switch lenders at renewal?
When this episode was recorded, only insured mortgages could switch without a new stress test. Since November 21, 2024, uninsured borrowers who switch lenders at renewal without increasing their loan also no longer need to re-qualify under the stress test.
What is an alternative or B lender?
It is a lender outside the big banks that uses more flexible qualifying rules. Alex says in late 2023 their rates were often only 0.25% to 0.5% higher than bank rates, plus a fee of about 1% to 2%, and they helped borrowers who could not pass the stress test.
What mortgage rule changes did the hosts want?
Steve proposed capping all prepayment penalties at three months’ interest and showing the penalty in online banking, Tom wanted larger lump sum prepayment limits, and Alex wanted 30 year amortizations for first time buyers and a lighter stress test at renewal.
Related: The Tom Storey Show episode guide · Next episode: Housing Is Out Of Reach For Most Canadians with The Canadian Real Estate Show
Show notes
***Start Your Realty Ninja Real Estate Website***
Free Trial and 20% Off your first year:
https://www.realtyninja.com/tom
Canadians in 2024 are more and more worried about being able to pay their new mortgage payments.
In this episode of The Tom Storey Show, Steve Karrasch and Tom Storey discuss mortgages and money with Alex McFadyen of Flow Mortgage Co.
Connect with Alex:
Web: https://www.getflowmortgage.ca/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/flowmortgageco/
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@flowmortgageco
*** Need Home or Property Insurance? ***
Use SQUARE ONE: Tenants, Landlords and Home Owners Save $20 with Square One Insurance using this link: https://www.squareone.ca/thetomstoreyshow?offer_code=TTSS
🎥 Learn how to improve your message with the #1 Real Estate Video Course or my YouTube Course for Real Estate *** https://videocourselogin.com/ ***
💵 DISCOUNT CODE: TomShow 💵
AUDIO PODCAST LINKS:
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/7wEEPUUhaC8g2CsIwJetbd
Apple Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/…/the-tom…/id1627632474
Amazon: https://music.amazon.ca/…/the-tom-storey-show-with…?
TOM STOREY
Book a call with Tom: https://calendly.com/TomStorey
Tom's YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/TomStorey/videos
The Storey Team, Royal LePage Signature: https://storeyteam.ca/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thestoreyteam/
FaceBook: https://www.facebook.com/thestoreyteam
STEVE KARRASCH
Book a call with Steve: https://calendly.com/stevekarrasch
Steve's YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/KarraschRealProperties/videos
Karrasch Real Properties, Macdonald Realty: https://www.krproperties.ca/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/karrasch_real_properties/
FaceBook: https://www.facebook.com/KarraschRealProperties/
Need VIDEO GEAR? Shop Steve's Amazon Store: https://amzn.to/45cIBbU
The opinions expressed herein are solely that of Steve Karrasch PREC and Tom Storey, not Macdonald Realty, Royal LePage Signature, TREB or the FVREB and should not be misconstrued as advice or the basis of an agency relationship whatsoever. Nor should any of this content be considered or used as financial advice. Please consult your professional advisor prior to taking action on any decisions relating to the matters discussed in these videos. This communication is not intended to cause or induce breach of an existing agency agreement.












