About this video Recorded in September 2020, this video compares two very different forecasts for Canadian home prices released the same day. CMHC’s then CEO told BNN that prices could still fall about 10% nationally, after earlier warning of a decline of up to 18%. CIBC chief economist Benjamin Tal instead expected a stable market, supported by higher household savings. Tom Storey sided with a stable outlook, and in the...
About this video
Recorded in September 2020, this video compares two very different forecasts for Canadian home prices released the same day. CMHC’s then CEO told BNN that prices could still fall about 10% nationally, after earlier warning of a decline of up to 18%. CIBC chief economist Benjamin Tal instead expected a stable market, supported by higher household savings. Tom Storey sided with a stable outlook, and in the end prices rose strongly through 2021.
Key points
- CMHC’s then CEO forecast a Canada wide price decline of about 10%, even if the worst case was avoided.
- Earlier in the pandemic the same forecast had called for a drop of up to 18%, yet prices had risen in most Canadian markets since then.
- CIBC chief economist Benjamin Tal expected housing to remain stable, partly because Canadians were saving much more while travel and spending were limited.
- Tal also expected the rental market to stay sluggish, which Tom agreed with until immigration resumed.
- Tom’s take: there is no single right answer, but people who predict a crash every year will eventually be right at some point.
- In Toronto, houses were still selling very well, while condos had moved to a balanced market with median prices down about 10% since the start of 2020.
The two forecasts side by side
| Source | Forecast for prices | Main reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| CMHC (then CEO, via BNN) | Down about 10% nationally | Economic damage from the pandemic |
| CIBC (Benjamin Tal) | Stable | Higher household savings |
What happened next
Neither decline arrived. Home prices rose strongly across most of Canada through 2021 and into early 2022, driven by low rates and strong demand. Prices then fell from that peak as the Bank of Canada raised rates in 2022 and 2023, and the bank began cutting again in June 2024.
Questions answered in this video
Did CMHC predict a housing price drop in 2020?
Yes. CMHC’s then CEO warned early in the pandemic that prices could fall up to 18%, and in September 2020 forecast a national decline of about 10%. Prices instead rose through 2021.
What did CIBC’s Benjamin Tal predict for housing in 2020?
He expected the market to stay stable, supported by higher household savings, and expected the rental market to stay sluggish for some time.
Why do housing forecasts differ so much?
Forecasters weigh factors like savings, jobs, interest rates and immigration differently. Tom suggests looking at local numbers rather than national headlines.
Toronto real estate outlook: 2020, The Toronto housing crash that never happened and Toronto real estate FAQ
📅 Book An Appointment: https://calendly.com/tomstorey
🏠 Search Listings and Sold Prices For FREE: https://tinyurl.com/ListSoldPrices
💾 DOWNLOAD Our FREE Guide For Buyers and Seller: https://stan.store/thestoreyteam
Serious about buying or selling Toronto Real Estate? Interview the Storey Team. You’ll be glad you did. https://storeyteam.ca/
The opinions expressed herein are solely that of Tom Storey, not Royal LePage or the TRREB and should not be misconstrued as advice or the basis of an agency relationship whatsoever. Please consult your professional advisor prior to taking action on any decisions relating to the matters discussed in these videos. This communication is not intended to cause or induce breach of an existing agency agreement. This is not financial advice.












