About this episode Niagara realtor Scott Fishman joins Tom Storey and Steve Krysak to explain what $450,000 to $650,000 buys across the Niagara region, why first time buyers came back after the federal election, how peak buyers are faring, why new builds are struggling, and his 70/20/10 rule for buying a home without regret. Hosts: Tom Storey (Toronto) and Steve Karrasch (Greater Vancouver)Guest: Scott Fishman, Niagara realtor, The Fishman GroupEpisode:...
About this episode
Niagara realtor Scott Fishman joins Tom Storey and Steve Krysak to explain what $450,000 to $650,000 buys across the Niagara region, why first time buyers came back after the federal election, how peak buyers are faring, why new builds are struggling, and his 70/20/10 rule for buying a home without regret.
Hosts: Tom Storey (Toronto) and Steve Karrasch (Greater Vancouver)
Guest: Scott Fishman, Niagara realtor, The Fishman Group
Episode: May 11, 2025, about 67 minutes
Watch this episode on YouTube or listen above.
Key takeaways
- Niagara had about 3,500 active listings in spring 2025, the most since 2009, and close to seven months of inventory, Scott says. Border towns such as Fort Erie and Niagara Falls feel extra uncertainty from tariffs.
- After the federal election, Scott says his phone started ringing with first time buyers who had been waiting. Homes between about $500,000 and $625,000 drew multiple offers, but still sold $20,000 to $30,000 under asking with conditions.
- What $450,000 buys varies widely: in Port Colborne or Fort Erie, often a move in ready two storey with three bedrooms and two bathrooms, and in St. Catharines, often a three bedroom, one bathroom bungalow downtown. Niagara Falls is more expensive.
- A front and back legal duplex in Port Colborne recently sold for about $365,000, with each unit renting for about $1,900. Scott says rents are similar across the region, while tenant quality varies by price point.
- Buyers who bought near the 2022 peak are down significantly. One home bought for $775,000 was listed at $625,000. Scott says most owners who are underwater are staying put unless they must move.
- Most first time buyers in Niagara are choosing homes that need work, Scott says, putting $40,000 to $50,000 into renovations to build a cushion in case values fall again.
- New builds are hard to sell because a new three bedroom on a 40 or 50 foot lot runs $750,000 to $800,000 when a similar resale home costs about $650,000. Many locals prefer a well kept older home to entry level new construction.
- Steve says sellers who reduce by only $5,000 at a time are chasing the market down. Scott’s message to sellers who forced appreciation through renovations: take your break even and capture future gains at the higher price point you move up to.
The 70/20/10 rule
Scott tells first time buyers that about 70% of a home should be what they actually want, 20% should be things they can change, and 10% should be things they can live with even though they cannot change them, such as the lot size or layout.
Short term rentals in Crystal Beach
Fort Erie issues a limited number of short term rental permits each year, and permits do not transfer to a new owner. Scott says investors who bought cottages to rent short term without a permit are now selling to locals at much lower prices.
Toronto buyers and the merged MLS
Since Niagara’s MLS merged with Toronto’s, Scott says some out of town agents have paid more than local buyers would, creating sales that confuse neighbouring sellers’ expectations. He believes local knowledge matters most for spotting streets and areas that will not appraise well.
Agents in a slow market
Scott says Niagara sales volume was down about 50% in the first quarter and morale is low. Steve says agents need to carry more listings because only a small share sell each month, and that agents who started in the boom must learn how hard selling a home normally is. Scott credits coaching for helping him run his business like a business.
This episode is general discussion and not financial advice.
Questions answered in this episode
What does $450,000 buy in the Niagara region?
Scott Fishman says it varies by town. In Port Colborne or Fort Erie it can buy a move in ready two storey home with three bedrooms and two bathrooms, while in St. Catharines it is more often a three bedroom, one bathroom bungalow downtown.
How many homes are for sale in Niagara?
In spring 2025, Scott Fishman says the region had about 3,500 active listings, the most since 2009, and close to seven months of inventory.
What is the 70/20/10 rule for buying a home?
Scott Fishman’s rule is that about 70% of a home should be what you want, 20% should be things you can change, and 10% should be things you cannot change but can live with.
Why are new build homes in Niagara not selling?
Scott Fishman says a new three bedroom home costs about $750,000 to $800,000 while a similar resale home is about $650,000, and many local buyers trust older, well kept homes more than entry level new construction.
Can I run a short term rental in Crystal Beach?
Scott Fishman says Fort Erie limits the number of short term rental permits each year, and a permit does not transfer when the property is sold, so a new owner must apply again.
Related: The Tom Storey Show episode guide · Next episode: lawyer Tony Spagnuolo
Show notes
**Start Your Realty Ninja Website** Free Trial: https://www.realtyninja.com/tomBook a call w/Tom for Toronto: https://calendly.com/TomStoreyBook a call w/Steve for Greater Vancouver: https://calendly.com/stevekarrasch*** Ontario Agents! Get Your Custom Branded TRESA Explainer Video TODAY! ***Order Here: https://tresavideo.ca/Promo Code: TOMSHOW*** Need Home or Property Insurance? *** Use SQUARE ONE: Tenants, Landlords and Home Owners Save $20 with Square One Insurance using this link: https://www.squareone.ca/thetomstoreyshow?offer_code=TTSS- – – Both Sellers and their Agents are going to have to get used to a slow market and build both the skills and knowledge required to get homes sold in 2025.In this episode of The Tom Storey Show, Steve Karrasch and Tom Storey speak with Niagara area agent Scott Fishman of The Agency to discuss current market trends. Connect with Scott:Web: https://fishmangroup.ca/Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/scottfishman_realtor/- – -🎥 Learn how to improve your message with the #1 Real Estate Video Course or my YouTube Course for Real Estate *** https://videocourselogin.com/ ***💵 DISCOUNT CODE: TomShow 💵AUDIO PODCAST LINKS:Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/7wEEPUUhaC8g2CsIwJetbdApple Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/…/the-tom…/id1627632474Amazon: https://music.amazon.ca/…/the-tom-storey-show-with…?TOM STOREYTom’s YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/TomStorey/videosThe Storey Team, Royal LePage Signature: https://storeyteam.ca/Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thestoreyteam/FaceBook: https://www.facebook.com/thestoreyteamSTEVE KARRASCHSteve’s YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/KarraschRealProperties/videosKarrasch Real Properties, Macdonald Realty: https://www.krproperties.ca/Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/karrasch_real_properties/FaceBook: https://www.facebook.com/KarraschRealProperties/Need VIDEO GEAR? Shop Steve’s Amazon Store: https://amzn.to/45cIBbUThe opinions expressed herein are solely that of Steve Karrasch PREC and Tom Storey, not Macdonald Realty, Royal LePage Signature, TREB or the FVREB and should not be misconstrued as advice or the basis of an agency relationship whatsoever. Nor should any of this content be considered or used as financial advice. Please consult your professional advisor prior to taking action on any decisions relating to the matters discussed in these videos. This communication is not intended to cause or induce breach of an existing agency agreement.












