About this episode Muskoka waterfront agent Holly Carroll joined Tom Storey and Steve Carrish in April 2023 to explain how the cottage market was holding up after rates rose. She said waterfront in Muskoka generally starts around $1 million and holds its value better than inland property, most buyers come from Toronto, and strong short term rental income keeps demand steady. Hosts: Tom Storey (Toronto) and Steve Karrasch (Greater Vancouver)Guest:...
About this episode
Muskoka waterfront agent Holly Carroll joined Tom Storey and Steve Carrish in April 2023 to explain how the cottage market was holding up after rates rose. She said waterfront in Muskoka generally starts around $1 million and holds its value better than inland property, most buyers come from Toronto, and strong short term rental income keeps demand steady.
Hosts: Tom Storey (Toronto) and Steve Karrasch (Greater Vancouver)
Guest: Holly Carroll, Waterfront real estate agent
Episode: April 9, 2023, about 68 minutes
Watch this episode on YouTube or listen above.
Key takeaways
- Holly Carroll specializes in waterfront properties in Muskoka, Haliburton and the Kawartha Lakes with The Agency.
- She said getting on the water in Muskoka generally starts at about $1 million, and listings under that are rarer and sell faster.
- Prices dipped with higher rates, but she said waterfront holds its value better than inland property and buyers were returning in spring 2023, in what she called almost a buyer’s market.
- Most of her buyers come from Toronto and the surrounding area and buy a second home, often with significant equity, so fewer owners are forced to sell.
- She said some buyers who stretched with low variable rates during the pandemic ran into trouble, and she advised owners who can hold to wait rather than sell at a loss.
- Muskoka has become a four season place since the pandemic, with Starlink internet available, and septic systems are a normal part of cottage ownership.
- Premium cottages can rent for about $10,000 to $30,000 a week in summer, and she said lenders had started counting half of short term rental income when qualifying buyers.
- Steve Carrish argued that disclosing competing offers would mainly help buyers with the deepest pockets, while Holly said it was unclear who the new realtor.ca open offers option would benefit.
What a cottage means in Muskoka
Holly described Muskoka as a luxury lake region where you can reach restaurants, shopping and towns by boat. She said many older family cottages have been rebuilt or upgraded, so original rustic cottages are now hard to find in the core lakes. Large, private lots on lakes such as Lake Rosseau have drawn high profile owners.
Short term rentals and features renters want
Holly said most lakes still rent well, not only the best known ones, and that a few areas require short term rental licences. Features such as cedar barrel saunas and hot tubs help a cottage stand out, and she expected wood fired soaking tubs to become a trend. Steve compared Muskoka with British Columbia, where resort areas like Whistler are farther from the city and far more expensive, and lake cottage culture is less common.
Showing cottages to buyers from the city
Because buyers usually drive up for the day, Holly speaks with them by phone before they arrive and plans a full day of showings, sometimes by boat. She said most cottage transactions involve a separate agent for each side, and that pocket listings are rare because the best exposure comes from marketing to a broad audience.
Marketing, coaching and confidence
Holly, a former international model and Miss Canada Tourism, said visibility matters because clients need to know who you are before they can choose you. She wrote a book for buyers and sellers, Selling Secrets You Can’t Afford to Miss, which she uses to build credibility, and said every agent should work with a coach. Her social media tip was to post with intention: share value, humour or inspiration, or skip the post.
Other perspectives
Supporters of open bidding argue that sharing offer details makes the process fairer and more transparent for buyers who would otherwise bid blind, and the federal government had promised to move away from blind bidding. Critics, including Steve, argue that closed bids protect the privacy of buyers and sellers and that open bidding tends to favour the buyer with the most money. The choice rests with the seller.
Update since this episode
Since Ontario’s TRESA phase 2 rules took effect on December 1, 2023, a seller can direct their brokerage to share the details of competing offers with buyers. The Bank of Canada raised its rate to 5% in July 2023, began cutting in June 2024 and was at 3.25% by the end of 2024.
Views are those of the guest and hosts and are not financial, legal or investment advice.
Questions answered in this episode
How much does a waterfront cottage cost in Muskoka?
In this April 2023 episode, Holly Carroll said getting on the water in Muskoka generally starts at about $1 million, with listings under that being rarer and selling faster. Prices vary widely by lake, frontage and the size of the cottage.
Who buys cottages in Muskoka?
Holly said most of her buyers come from Toronto and the surrounding area and buy a second home. Many have significant equity or cash, which she said helps keep the waterfront market stable.
How much do Muskoka cottages rent for?
She said premium cottages can rent for about $10,000 to $30,000 a week in summer, depending on size, number of bedrooms and amenities such as saunas and hot tubs.
Can short term rental income help you qualify for a cottage mortgage?
Holly said in April 2023 that some lenders had started counting about half of short term rental income when qualifying buyers. Lender policies vary, so buyers should confirm with a mortgage professional.
Can sellers in Ontario share competing offer details?
Yes. Since December 1, 2023, under Ontario’s TRESA rules, a seller can direct their brokerage to disclose the details of competing offers. Sellers can still choose a traditional blind process.
Related: The Tom Storey Show episode guide · Next episode: The Failing US Banking System & Impact On Canadian Real Estate with Jon Bye
Show notes
Have these increased interest rates and the return to city centres provided cottage owners no choice but to sell their Canadian Cottages?
Holly Carroll is a Luxury Real Estate Agent with The Agency and sells properties in Muskoka Ontario and this week she joins Steve Karrasch and Tom Storey on “The Tom Storey Show” to discuss her market and experiences in real estate.
Connect with Holly:
Instagram: https://instagram.com/hollyanncarroll?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y=
Get Holly’s Book: https://hollycarroll.book.live/ca-biz-card-book
They Ask, You Answer By Marcus Sheridan: https://amzn.to/3LXHHtR
DOWNLOAD LENDLORD for free OR get 90 Days of the paid version using this link: https://www.lendlord.io/tomshow
– – –
Subscribe on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCse8VG5r3C9O9S7W6-p5sNg?sub_confirmation=1
🎥 Learn how to improve your message with the #1 Real Estate Video Course or my YouTube Course for Real Estate *** https://videocourselogin.com/ ***
💵 DISCOUNT CODE: TomShow 💵
AUDIO PODCAST LINKS:
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/7wEEPUUhaC8g2CsIwJetbd
Apple Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/…/the-tom…/id1627632474
Amazon: https://music.amazon.ca/…/the-tom-storey-show-with…?
Anchor: https://anchor.fm/s/9879d360/podcast/rss
TOM STOREY
Book a call with Tom: https://calendly.com/TomStorey
Tom's YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/TomStorey/videos
The Storey Team, Royal LePage Signature: https://storeyteam.ca/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thestoreyteam/
FaceBook: https://www.facebook.com/thestoreyteam
STEVE KARRASCH
Book a call with Steve: https://calendly.com/stevekarrasch
Steve's YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/KarraschRealProperties/videos
Karrasch Real Properties, Macdonald Realty: https://www.krproperties.ca/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/karrasch_real_properties/
FaceBook: https://www.facebook.com/KarraschRealProperties/
Video Gear:
Microphone: https://amzn.to/3mim9u5
Interview Microphones: https://amzn.to/3nzryhx
Studio Lights: https://amzn.to/3r8uLoY
Ring Light: https://amzn.to/3ACAIPg
Mobile Light: https://amzn.to/337evN9
Wall Mount Boom: https://amzn.to/3fjtaHq
Teleprompter: https://amzn.to/3tg1iwg
Teleprompter Screen: https://amzn.to/3qef54m
Power Supply: https://amzn.to/3qYpe4o
USBC Hub: https://amzn.to/3r2ACw1
The opinions expressed herein are solely that of Steve Karrasch PREC and Tom Storey, not Macdonald Realty, Royal LePage Signature, TREB or the FVREB and should not be misconstrued as advice or the basis of an agency relationship whatsoever. Nor should any of this content be considered or used as financial advice. Please consult your professional advisor prior to taking action on any decisions relating to the matters discussed in these videos. This communication is not intended to cause or induce breach of an existing agency agreement.
#cottagecountry #muskokarealestate #realestatecanada












