About this episode Niagara appraiser and realtor Ben Ellens joined Tom Storey and Steve Carrish in March 2023 to explain how home appraisals work, why they can come in below the purchase price when markets move quickly, and what buyers and agents can do about it. He also shared what homes cost in St. Catharines and how far Niagara prices had fallen from the peak. Hosts: Tom Storey (Toronto) and...
About this episode
Niagara appraiser and realtor Ben Ellens joined Tom Storey and Steve Carrish in March 2023 to explain how home appraisals work, why they can come in below the purchase price when markets move quickly, and what buyers and agents can do about it. He also shared what homes cost in St. Catharines and how far Niagara prices had fallen from the peak.
Hosts: Tom Storey (Toronto) and Steve Karrasch (Greater Vancouver)
Guest: Ben Ellens, Accredited appraiser (AACI) and real estate agent
Episode: March 19, 2023, about 74 minutes
Watch this episode on YouTube or listen above.
Key takeaways
- Ben Ellens has about 10 years of experience as an appraiser with an AACI designation, the highest real property designation from the Appraisal Institute of Canada, and has also been a realtor in Niagara since 2019.
- Appraisers rely on past sales, so in the first one to three months of a fast rising market, appraisals often lag behind what buyers are paying.
- Some lenders require appraisers to use only closed sales, while Ellens said firm but not yet closed sales can be the best evidence when prices are moving quickly, as long as the report explains why.
- An appraisal ordered weeks after a deal firms up can rely on sales from a different market; he and the hosts recommended ordering appraisals early, ideally before financing conditions are waived.
- A full residential appraisal requires an on site inspection, while drive by and desktop appraisals rely more on outside information, and some insured mortgages are approved with an automated valuation instead.
- If an appraisal comes in low, the buyer can make up the difference or the lender may agree to a value appeal, which works best with a short list of truly comparable sales.
- In Niagara, Ellens said prices rose about 2% a month during the run up and were down about 20% to 25% from the peak in early 2023, back to roughly spring 2021 levels.
- He said market value is a range, not a single number, and that one outlier sale does not set the value of a whole market.
Appraisal designations and what appraisers value
Ellens explained that the Appraisal Institute of Canada has two designations: CRA for residential properties with up to four units, and AACI for all types of real property, from homes to farms, wineries and development land. Every valuation starts with the highest and best use of the property, which is why development land and even air rights above a site can carry significant value.
What a home costs in Niagara
Ellens said the average price across the Niagara region was just under $700,000 in early 2023. In north St. Catharines, a three bedroom bungalow from the 1950s or 1960s on a 50 by 100 foot lot was selling for about $750,000 to $850,000 depending on condition. He estimated about half of his deals involved buyers from the GTA looking for more space for their money, and said the region was close to tipping from a balanced market into a seller’s market.
Different values for the same property
Steve noted that agents can give an opinion of value for a sale but not for every purpose. Ellens explained that an apartment building with long term tenants paying well below market rent can be worth much less to a lender than its price per unit suggests, because the leases limit the income. He also described value in use, where a specialized property such as a busy storage facility may be worth far less if it had to be converted to another use.
Why four appraisers can reach four numbers
Ellens said different results usually come down to comparable selection. If a comparable needs adjustments of more than about 10%, it is likely the wrong comparable. He gave the example of a single sale of farmland in Niagara on the Lake at about $175,000 an acre, compared with about $50,000 to $60,000 an acre for most planted farmland, and said one sale does not reset the whole market.
Update since this episode
The Bank of Canada, which had paused in March 2023, raised its rate again in June and July 2023 to 5%, then began cutting in June 2024 and was at 3.25% by the end of 2024. Lower rates have improved affordability for buyers, though appraisals still rely on recent comparable sales in each local market.
Views are those of the guest and hosts and are not financial, legal or investment advice.
Questions answered in this episode
Why do home appraisals come in lower than the purchase price?
Appraisers base value on recent comparable sales. Ben Ellens said that when prices rise quickly, or when an appraisal is ordered long after a deal firms up, the available sales may not reflect what a buyer agreed to pay.
What happens if an appraisal comes in low?
The buyer may need to cover the gap with a larger down payment, or the lender may agree to a second appraisal or a value appeal. Ellens recommended submitting a short list of truly comparable sales with any appeal.
When should an appraisal be ordered?
Ellens and the hosts recommended ordering the appraisal as early as possible, ideally during the financing condition period, so there are no surprises close to closing.
What is the difference between a full appraisal and a drive by appraisal?
A full residential appraisal requires the appraiser to inspect the home in person. A drive by appraisal is done from the street and relies more on listing information, and a desktop appraisal is done entirely from records and data.
What is an AACI appraiser?
AACI stands for Accredited Appraiser Canadian Institute, the highest designation from the Appraisal Institute of Canada. AACI appraisers can value any type of real property, while CRA appraisers focus on residential properties with up to four units.
Related: The Tom Storey Show episode guide · Next episode: Canadian Real Estate Developers Are EVIL! with Darryl Frankfort
Show notes
Real estate appraisals have come under a lot of fire in the recent years with the market run up and eventual correction. Some say that appraisals are a huge part of the problem in Canadian Housing.
In this episode of The Tom Storey Show, Steve Karrasch and Tom Storey sit down with real estate agent AND appraiser Ben Ellens of Niagara & St Catherines Ontario to discuss the market and so much more.
Connect with Ben
Email: benellens@rcellens.ca
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ben.ellens/?next=%2F
Reviews: https://tinyurl.com/3ktuya2c
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/benellens/
Website: https://www.rcellens.ca/
– – –
DOWNLOAD LENDLORD for free OR get 90 Days of the paid version using this link: https://www.lendlord.io/tomshow
– – –
Subscribe on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCse8VG5r3C9O9S7W6-p5sNg?sub_confirmation=1
🎥 Learn how to improve your message with the #1 Real Estate Video Course or my YouTube Course for Real Estate *** https://videocourselogin.com/ ***
💵 DISCOUNT CODE: TomShow 💵
AUDIO PODCAST LINKS:
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/7wEEPUUhaC8g2CsIwJetbd
Apple Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/…/the-tom…/id1627632474
Amazon: https://music.amazon.ca/…/the-tom-storey-show-with…?
Anchor: https://anchor.fm/s/9879d360/podcast/rss
TOM STOREY
Book a call with Tom: https://calendly.com/TomStorey
Tom’s YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/TomStorey/videos
The Storey Team, Royal LePage Signature: https://storeyteam.ca/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thestoreyteam/
FaceBook: https://www.facebook.com/thestoreyteam
STEVE KARRASCH
Book a call with Steve: https://calendly.com/stevekarrasch
Steve’s YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/KarraschRealProperties/videos
Karrasch Real Properties, Macdonald Realty: https://www.krproperties.ca/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/karrasch_real_properties/
FaceBook: https://www.facebook.com/KarraschRealProperties/
Video Gear:
Microphone: https://amzn.to/3mim9u5
Interview Microphones: https://amzn.to/3nzryhx
Studio Lights: https://amzn.to/3r8uLoY
Ring Light: https://amzn.to/3ACAIPg
Mobile Light: https://amzn.to/337evN9
Wall Mount Boom: https://amzn.to/3fjtaHq
Teleprompter: https://amzn.to/3tg1iwg
Teleprompter Screen: https://amzn.to/3qef54m
Power Supply: https://amzn.to/3qYpe4o
USBC Hub: https://amzn.to/3r2ACw1
The opinions expressed herein are solely that of Steve Karrasch PREC and Tom Storey, not Macdonald Realty, Royal LePage Signature, TREB or the FVREB and should not be misconstrued as advice or the basis of an agency relationship whatsoever. Nor should any of this content be considered or used as financial advice. Please consult your professional advisor prior to taking action on any decisions relating to the matters discussed in these videos. This communication is not intended to cause or induce breach of an existing agency agreement.
#RealEstateAppraisals #RealEstateCanada #CanadaHousing












